Dvorak Cello Concerto
Berlin Symphony (Berliner Symphoniker) conducted by Gaetano Delogu
No one has composed for the
cello with more abandon than Dvorak. To play him
the soloist is obliged to enter an orchestral
jungle, and here there was no concealing the fact
that the Armenian Karine Georgian was a student of
the great Rostropovich. Georgian hurtled into
attack, penetrating deep into the seething wall of
sound to emerge triumphant in both style and tone.
The performance was received with rapturous
applause.
Die Welt, Berlin
Berlin Symphony (Berliner Symphoniker) conducted by Gaetano Delogu
Karine Georgian studied with the great Mstislav
Rostropovich and his influence was clearly
discernible in her performance of Dvoraks
Cello Concerto. She brought that same austere,
hard-edged tone, allied with power and uninhibited
expression, to the well-known piece. However, this
great cellist is by no means a pale imitation of
Rostropovich. She stormed through the work with a
passion which stems from a wholly personal,
deep-felt commitment. Although she raced through
the music at breathtaking speed, she took time to
dwell lovingly on the details. The Berlin Symphony
Orchestra, now renamed the Berliner Symphoniker,
gave the soloist vigorous support. Italian
conductor Gaetano Delogu held the orchestra
together and succeeded in bringing out the full
flavour of the concertos Slavic melancholy.
The performance developed into one of the high
points of this season.
Berliner Morgenpost
Orchestra of RAI, Torino conducted by Yuri Temirkanov
The performance of Dvoraks Cello Concerto,
one of the most beautiful of all Romantic works,
enjoyed tremendous success at the RAI Studios
yesterday evening. Karine Georgian, an Armenian
pupil of Rostropovich, treated the piece with
beautiful delicacy. The tone of her instrument is
not particularly strong, but it is particularly
delightful with its delicate softness, smoothly
penetrating the gently pastoral, delicate,
tormented and inspired melancholy of this
Concerto, blurring its contrasts, while the theme
proceeds sweetly blending with subtle and sensuous
links. When the first movement abandons its
triumphant melody to develop into subdued and
discreet harmony, almost dissolving in a cloud of
nostalgia it forms a remarkable transition that
the soloist exploited to perfection, supported by
an exceptional conductor.
La Stampa
Orchestra of RAI, Torino conducted by Yuri Temirkanov
For her debut with the Turin orchestra Karine
Georgian chose Dvoraks Concerto. An
outstanding choice, and her performance was a
revelation. An exquisite performer whom we hope to
be able to hear again soon, since with such
lyrical sensibility and such precious and resonant
transparency she will offer us classical music of
rare perfection.
Repubblica
Hamburg Symphoniker conducted by Heribert Beissel
On her third guest appearance with the Hamburg
Symphoniker in the Grosse Musikhalle the Russian
cellist Karine Georgian succeeded in generating a
mesmeric enthusiasm in excess even of everything
to which we have become accustomed from this
former Rostropovich pupil. She played
Dvoraks B minor Concerto with unparalleled
and impassioned commitment, as if drunk with her
own conception of the work. The result was a
uniquely expressive song for the cello.
Hamburger Abendblatt
Hamburg Symphoniker conducted by Heribert Beissel
What a woman, with the power to make her cello
bewitch the hearts of her audience! Karine
Georgian, now celebrated as one of the leading
cellists of our time, was yesterdays soloist
with the Hamburger Symphoniker in the Grosse
Musikhalle.
The high point of the evening there can be
not the slightest doubt about this was the
Cello Concerto in B minor Op 104 by Antonin Dvorak
with Karine Georgian as soloist. Her playing goes
beyond what words can express; it begins there
where speech falters or can simply no longer
reach. If this sounds exaggerated, it comes direct
from the heart: her music-making speaks for
itself, and to it one can only listen and remain
silent.
Hamburger Auszeiger und Nachrichten
London Festival Orchestra conducted by Ross Pople, Queen Elisabeth Hall
In the second movement she played eloquently and
movingly; the freedom of the long, languid phrases
suited her unreserved ardour. Pople conducted with
sensitivity to Georgians complex musicality
and was rewarded with some readily penetrating
solos from the oboe, although the horn section
occasionally gave cause for concern in sustained
passages with unsure entries, breath control
problems and clipped diminuendos. Despite these
very minor grievances the movement finished with
such sublimity that the concert hall resounded
with the silence before it burst with the new
glories of the third movement. This was a
colourful display of well articulated chromatic
passages and preserved rhythmic integrity exuding
enthusiasm proportionate to the first movement.
All suspicions of enacting integrity were
dismissed at this point. She is an aggressive and
robust performer, unhindered by any consciousness
of self on stage.
The Strad
Hudson Valley Philharmonic conducted by Imre Pallo
Karine Georgians performance with the Hudson
Valley Philharmonic Friday evening in
Dvoraks Cello Concerto, extraordinary for
its profundity of conception and perfection of
execution, was the sleeper of the decade for this
symphonic series. Her cello entrance struck like
an emotional depth charge, transforming a musical
scene of pretty nostalgia to an excursion in
Slavic soul. Its possible to dissect
Georgians performance precise
intonation in the midst of dervish polyphonics
with doubled and tripled lines given simultaneous
and individual voicing but extraordinary
technical effects are simply not the point of her
artistry. They are assimilated to necessary
expression, resonant with whatever passions of
sorrow, tenderness and sensuality she shares with
the concertos composer.
Daily Freeman
Ulster Orchestra conducted by Gilbert Varga
Gilbert Varga was the conductor and without the
usual curtain-raiser the concert began with
Dvoraks Cello Concerto, in the opinion of
many the greatest of all cello concertos. The
soloist was Karine Georgian, remembered for her
performance of Tchaikovskys Rococo
Variations with the St. Petersburg
Philharmonic Orchestra but heard from a different
seat this time. Inspired by the Irish composer
Victor Herbert, Dvoraks inspired concerto is
a masterpiece, to the performance of which Ms.
Georgian brought a formidable array of talent,
technical security, finely shaped phrases and
lustrous tone.
Belfast Telegraph
BBC Scottish Symphony Orchestra conducted by Fyodor Glushchenko
Dvoraks Cello Concerto in the first half was
less fluid, though soloist Karine Georgian played
with passion and soul
The Herald
Elgar Cello Concerto
Royal Scottish National Orchestra conducted by Yuri Temirkanov
Between these works, Elgars cello concerto
provided an essential point of repose, in intimacy
of utterance if not in mood. Karine Georgian, the
Russian soloist, possessed the same ability to dig
beneath the musics surface which the
conductor had revealed in the Mussorgsky. She
played it, to admiration, as if it were a short
story by Chekhov.
Corad Wilson, The Scotsman
Royal Scottish National Orchestra conducted by Yuri Temirkanov
By half time, the ecstacy of audience (and
orchestra) response was more appropriate to the
end of a show. But there was more. Much more. On
came Karine Georgian to play the Elgar Cello
Concerto. Well, she didnt play it. She took
us into its soul. Sod your English lyricism,
breadth of landscape and all that tosh. The
Armenian cellist what a player
outlined a poignant, melancholic, passionate,
psychological study whose restraint and intensity
did momentarily suggest that the evening ought to
stop right there.
Michael Tumelty, The Herald
Orquesta Nacional dEspaña conducted by Carlos Kalmar
Those who did not attend the concert at the
Principe de Vergara Avenue Hall missed something
great: the superb performance by Russian cellist
Karine Georgian, now living in Germany where she
is successor to the great André Navarra at
the Hochschule für Musik in Detmold. Miss
Georgian played in so splendidly creative a
manner, with such extraordinary technical command
and expressive power, blended with a quality of
sound that enhanced the whole performance, that to
quote the well-known Spanish saying one
might spend ones time differently, but it is
impossible to spend it better.
El Pais
Colorado Music Festival Orchestra conducted by Gloria Bernstein
When you think about it, why should it be
surprising for a Russian cellist to respond warmly
to the nobility and nostalgia of Sir Edward
Elgars music? Thats what Karine
Georgian did last night in a deeply felt
interpretation of Elgars songfully sad Cello
Concerto of 1919 in a performance with the
Colorado Music Festival Orchestra under music
director Gloria Bernstein at Chautauqua
Auditorium. From the dark chords of the opening,
followed by the sweeping melancholia of the big E
minor melody, Georgian poured burnished tone and
powerful technique into one of the 20th
centurys finest works. Her arpeggios,
harmonics, pizzicato and gradations of tone were
reminders that she once studied in Moscow with
perhaps the finest cellist of the age, Mstislav
Rostropovich.
Denver Post
Royal Liverpool Philharmonic Orchestra conducted by Libor Pesek
From the opening solo bars of Elgars Cello
Concerto in E minor this concert was always going
to be a Festival highlight. After the
cellists emphatic opening phrase there
followed a seamless start to the first full
orchestral statement and it was obvious that
Karine Georgian was, in her playing, to add an
Eastern passion and intensity to the works
essential Englishness. She made emotion hang in
the air, leaving resolutions to the last possible
moment and one did not dare turn an eye or ear for
fear of missing the slightest nuance. A real
candidate for another of my greatest
ever concert review lists.
Eastern Daily Press
Tchaikovsky Rococo Variations
BBC Proms
Royal Scottish National Orchestra conducted by Neeme Jårvi
The real news was Karine Georgians
performance. It seemed to contain both more notes
and more beauty than the piece commonly yields.
Hilary Finch, The Times
St. Petersburg Philharmonic Orchestra conducted by Yuri Temirkanov
Cellist Karine Georgian was soloist in
Tchaikovskys Variations on a Rococo Theme
and her formidable technique and the singing
quality of her playing meant that she was always a
commanding performer. Conductor Yuri Temirkanov
ensured a good balance between orchestra and
soloist and brought a tight performance all round.
Belfast Telegraph
Moscow Philharmonic Orchestra conducted by Yuri Simonov
The centrepiece, Tchaikovskys Rococo
Variations for Cello and Orchestra, was performed
by the phenomenal cellist Karine Georgian. Her
rendition showed consummate control of a complex
and intricate work which overwhelmed the audience.
Swinging from fervourous passion to balletic
grace, the seven variations echoed
Tchaikovskys fever and zeal with every note.
The cellist built up a stirring crescendo which
gained rapturous applause and gave the audience an
opportunity to exhale after the spellbinding
performance.
Yorkshire Evening Post
Orchestra of RAI, Milano conducted by Vladimir Delman
The cellist Karine Georgian had a great success with her virtuoso performance
of Variations on a Rococo Theme. A complete triumph.
Corriere della Sera
Spokane Symphony conducted by Vakhtang Jordania
Karine Georgian is a brilliant Russian cellist, a
winner of the Tchaikovsky Competition, whose work
is too little known in this country. There need to
be more artists like this performing Tchaikovsky.
Georgian made Tchaikovskys Variations on a
Rococo Theme appear to be something that it is
not, namely eloquent. It is a conventional display
piece, alternating spectacular virtuosity. It
practically invites overstatement. Georgian, like
a brilliant, refined actress playing a highly
romantic role, never emoted. Her technique allowed
her to be playful in places such as the skittering
duet with flute, then oboe, in the fourth
variation. And her elegant, refined tone made the
songful parts sing without sobbing. Jordania and
the orchestra responded flexibly to
Georgians playing.
Spokane Spokesman-Review
Haydn Cello Concerto in C
Hamburg Symphoniker conducted by Horia Andreescu
Cantilena-Enchantress
Joy unconfined over Karine Georgian in the
Musikhalle: such was the excitement of the
audience and so all-embracing and sustained was
the applause for the master-cellist at the
conclusion of Haydns C major Concerto that
nobody even thought of letting the interval begin.
Everyone was on fire for her, and a very
rare event at an orchestral concert the
Hamburg Symphoniker and its guest conductor
responded to the sensational success of the
soloist by encoring the Finale of the Concerto.
It was performed by Karine Georgian in a dream of
precision with the fleetest of bow-strokes. This
was an Allegro molto in which the
molto was underlined. It has been
twelve years since the celebrated Rostropovich
pupil was last heard here, and last night the
Hamburg public fêted her as a revelation,
succumbing totally to the enchantment of her
cantilena. The virtuoso, who hails from Russia but
is now domiciled in the West with a professorship
at the Detmold Musikhocschule, is one of the
greatest of her breed. She should certainly not
allow such a long interval to elapse before she
visits us again.
Die Welt
Hamburg Symphoniker conducted by Horia Andreescu
The outstanding event in the fourth of the Hamburg
Symphoniker Subscription Concerts was the
performance by the soloist Karine Georgian of
Haydns C major Cello Concerto. Twelve years
ago the former master-student of Rostropovich, now
herself Professor in Detmold, played the Prokofiev
Symphony-Concerto with the same orchestra, and
again she displayed her mastery with a sensitive
and poetic account, replete with inner freedom, of
the solo part. Her heavenly tone raised the level
of the whole work far above that of a mere
virtuoso vehicle, especially in the insanely
mercurial, buzzing Finale which, in
acknowledgement of the applause in the Grosse
Musikhalle, had to be repeated.
Hamburger Abendblatt
Lausanne Chamber Orchestra conducted by Jesus Lopez Cobos
Suppleness
In Haydns C major Concerto the crisp,
tautly-sprung vigour of the orchestral
accompaniment was a match for that of the soloist,
Karine Georgian. This former Rostropovich pupil
from Moscow has clearly forgotten nothing of her
teachers inspiration: a sound at once
velvety and ample, ideally balanced throughout all
registers, a filigree, airy virtuosity at the
service of a musicality that gave life to the
moderato and the adagio movements that throbbed
with the tenderness flowing from her exceptionally
supple and expressive bow. The quivering intensity
of the Finale conveyed a wonderfully youthful and
joyous brio. A superb performance.
Gazette de Lausanne
Lausanne Chamber Orchestra conducted by Jesus Lopez Cobos
What, in addition to a never-failing musicality
even in the most virtuosic passages, is so
striking about Karine Georgian, soloist in
Haydns C major Cello Concerto, is the
evenness of her sound, warm and full even in the
most exposed high registers. The energy of her
bowing is not achieved at the expense of grace and
dexterity; velocity is never indulged in for show.
Karine Georgian maintained complete control of
tempo, articulation and phrasing even in the most
dangerous twists and turns of the Finale.
24 Heures Lausanne
Shostakovich Cello Concerto No. 1
BBC Scottish Symphony Orchestra conducted by Jerzy Maksymiuk
Constant Lambert once remarked that English
critics appeared to abide by the motto: bove
all no enthusiasm. Anyone so minded would
have had a hard time at the Sheldonian last Friday
when the superlative playing of the BBC Scottish
Symphony Orchestra was outshone only by the cello
soloist, Armenian-born Karine Georgian.
Shostakovichs First Cello Concerto allowed
for ample demonstration of Miss Georgians
virtuosity, especially in the extraordinary
cadenza movement. In spite of Oxfords wealth
of musical talent, there will be few better
evenings for concert-goers this autumn.
Oxford Times
Scottish Philharmonic Orchestra conducted by Peter Cyfryn, Oran Mor, Glasgow
Some players seem to embrace their instrument
rather than merely hold it. Karine Georgian became
indivisible from her cello during a performance of
the First Concerto of Dmitry Shostakovich that
produced an atmosphere unlike any other at these
early evening concerts. While the standard of
performance has like the audience
been building over the season, this closing event
was of a different order altogether: a performance
of the music that was right out of the top drawer.
Georgians playing had attack in spades from
the first bars and then lovely liquid phrasing in
the second movement, but nothing prepared the
audience for the mesmerising quality of her solo
cadenza later. She produced moments of aching
stillness which were quite new at Oran Mor.
The Herald
New Mexico Symphony Orchestra conducted by Andrew Parrott
From the start the New Mexico Symphony Orchestra
was a unified ensemble under the guidance of
Andrew Parrott. Cellist Karine Georgian was
mesmerizing in her performance of Dmitri
Shostakovichs Concerto No. 1 in E major Op
107. She brought a broad range of expression that
matched that of this terrifying work. Her
concentration throughout was remarkable. So intent
was she that the cello as her medium virtually
disappeared, leaving her in direct communication
with her audience. Listeners appeared to be held
in rapt attention. The NMSO offered an empathetic
accompaniment that enhanced the impact of the
work. It was a gripping performance.
Albuquerque Journal
San Jose Symphony conducted by Leonid Grin
The New Years emotional high point is
immutably embedded in the fiery Shostakovich Cello
Concerto No. 1 which the San Jose Symphony is
currently performing at the Center for the
Performing Arts. Russian soloist Karine Georgian
and Music Director Leonid Grin combined on an
electric journey through the high drama of this
large-scale work that provided the keystone of the
years opening concert Friday night. The
émigré Russian cellist transported
her listeners to a distant world constantly
teetering on the brink of rage and despair.
Intensity was certainly there, but unlike her
famed mentor Mstislav Rostropovich, Georgian did
not play the music like a musician possessed. Her
slow movement evoked a tender rapture with her
breathtakingly beautiful, mellow tone. And her
long cadenza conjured up provocative questions of
the soul and mind. The profoundly moving half-hour
performance demonstrated that there is more than
one way to interpret a work rich with ideas and
feelings.
San Jose Mercury News
Shostakovich Cello Concerto No. 2
Los Angeles Philharmonic conducted by Yuri Temirkanov
The centerpiece of the program should have been
the local premiere of Alfred Schnittkes
Cello Concerto. But a strange thing happened.
Although Temirkanov had at least a year to prepare
for the modernist challenge, he eventually turned
his back on his countryman, pleading
inadequate time to live with this
music. Enter Shostakovichs Second
Cello Concerto.
One must regret the cancellation of any work by
Schnittke. Even Temirkanov labels this much
troubled composer, much celebrated composer
a genius. At the same time, one must
always be grateful for an opportunity to hear a
stylish performance of the dark, sparse and
forbidding Shostakovich showpiece. Karine
Georgian, making her Philharmonic debut, conveyed
its piquant lyricism, its grotesquerie and melodic
violence with virtuosic aplomb. Unlike some
colleagues including her mentor, Mstislav
Rostropovich she did not rip into the piece
with fierce theatricality. She concentrated on
muted passions, yet sacrificed no expressive
intensity in the process.
Martin Bernheimer, Los Angeles Times
Los Angeles Philharmonic conducted by Yuri Temirkanov
Karine Georgian, 1966 Gold Medalist in
Moscows Tchaikovsky Competition, was the
splendid soloist in the Second Cello Concerto of
Shostakovich: glistening, sinister music
wondrously played. Perhaps the First Concerto has
more emotional depth, but this work is, in all
ways, a startling sound exercise. Most interesting
of all is the strange clickety-clack for
percussion right at the end, a curious
anticipation of the Fifteenth Symphony. Its quiet,
inward, solo writing has few rewards for a mere
virtuoso. Georgian, who has given much of her time
to the new music of her Soviet countrymen, brought
to the work the intelligence and imagination it
requires. She is clearly a major artist, here for
the first time.
Alan Rich, Daily News
Gubaidulina Seven Words
London Sinfonietta, Queen Elizabeth Hall, London
Sofia Gubaidulinas Seven Words (1982) has had several performances in this
country, but none surely better balanced than here by the conductor Markus
Stenz. The religious theme, originally disguised, is typical of the composers
Soviet period, but still the work is not at all retrospective. It takes the
form of a seven-movement chamber concert for cello, accordion and string
orchestra. Karine Georgians big, majestic cello tone and the powerful stabbing
chords and flashes of silvery brilliance from James Crabbs accordion sustained
interest where motifs are used a little repetitively.
John Allison, The Times
London Sinfonietta, Queen Elizabeth Hall, London
Seven Words is a chamber concerto for cello, bayan
(free-bass accordion) and strings, in seven
movements played without a break. The work is
steeped in musical symbolism: the cello not only
signifies the soul of Christ but as each string is
crossed a crucifixion is suffered to
the point where after I thirst the bow
transcends the bridge to play on the other
side. The bayan representing the body of
Christ initially works with the cello as a
concertino. Gudabidulina introduces almost human
qualities to the sounds of the bayan
horrifying inhalations and screams as the
crucifixion is carried out. The extraordinary
soloists were Karine Georgian (cello) and James
Crabb (bayan).
Annette Morreau, The Independent
Khachaturian Cello Rhapsody
Chicago Symphony Orchestra conducted by Aram Khachaturian
She takes total control the minute the music
begins, plunging directly in with the command and
technical assurance of a master.
Chicago Tribune
Schnittke Cello Concerto No. 1
American Composers Orchestra conducted by Paul Dunkel, Carnegie Hall (US premiere)
The biggest work was the Cello Concerto by the
Soviet avant-gardist Alfred Schnittke, which
received its U. S. premiere. Its a companion
piece to Schnittkes Viola Concerto
both run a bit over 40 minutes and were written in
1985. This is music of intense conflict,
Brucknerian majesty, and death-haunted tragedy (as
accented by tolling bells at many crucial points).
Yet the concertos message concludes in a
mood of eloquent, exalted consolation;
Schnittkes concerto is by far the most
religious-sounding work to have come out of the
Soviet Union in perhaps decades. The performance,
with Armenian cellist Karine Georgian, was
magnificent.
Bill Zakariasen, Daily News
Niederrheinischer Sinfoniker conducted by Yakov Kreizberg
Despite the great differences separating them,
both works [Schnittkes Cello Concerto No. 1
and Tchaikovskys Symphony No. 6] share a
similar basis in the pain experienced by the
individual conflicting with and confronting the
world in which he finds himself. The Schnittke
brought a renewed acquaintance with the cellist
Karine Georgian. So profound and personal was the
intensity with which this great and unassuming
artist played the work that one became prey to a
feeling that Schnittke might even have had in mind
a hint of a feminine sensibility when writing it.
Karine Georgians wonderful instrumental
voice, her clarity and strength in tone and
phrasing, is put at the service of a presence that
is as powerful when set confrontationally against
the orchestra as it is in monologues expressive of
the loneliness of the individual, and also in
unity and dialogue with the surrounding world, as
in this work the condition of our times is so
sublimely presented.
Karine Georgian lends to this frequently quiet,
gentle voice a quite special quality of passionate
intensity. With astonishing power throughout a
work whose roots lie as much in the traditions of
European culture as in the original character of
our own times, she never allows the tension
demanded of her as exponent of the artistic
material to flag. The subsequent applause for, and
universally favourable reaction to, this modernist
composition speaks for itself.
Westdeutsche Zeitung
Niederrheinischer Sinfoniker conducted by Yakov Kreizberg
A severe test for the Armenian cellist Karine
Georgian, who made her debut here two years ago in
Pendereckis Second Cello Concerto. With
great devotion the virtuoso player plunged deep
into the powerful but never violent sound world of
her part.
Rheinische Post
Niederrheinischer Sinfoniker conducted by Yakov Kreizberg
Alfred Schnittkes Cello Concert imposed on
the soloist Karine Georgian not only the most
formidable imaginable technical demands, but even
more so musical ones. She showed that not only had
she fully grown into her part, but had the freedom
to shape it with great persuasiveness. Well-versed
in contemporary music, she held the audience in
the palm of her hand, just as she
played with the orchestra. For the
public too this concerto is a tough nut: its
extreme length and idiosyncratic sound world make
plenty of demands on them, but the sustained
applause was evidence that they had enjoyed this
music.
Westdeutsche Zeitung
Penderecki Cello Concerto No. 2
BBC Philharmonic conducted by Krsysztof Penderecki
Karine Georgian countered that problem [criticism
of Pendereckis Christmas Symphony, also in
the programme] in her playing of his Second Cello
Concerto of 1982. The sheer energy she displayed,
in a work that certainly does not play itself,
generated a degree of ebb and flow to which the
orchestra responded magnificently.
David Fallows, The Times
Concertgebouw Orchestra conducted by Yakov Kreizberg
It must be said that Karine Georgian applied
herself with heartwarming virtuosity to the task
of injecting life into the concerto. Far from
incidental, in its slow passages, was her splendid
singing tone.
Het Parool
Concertgebouw Orchestra conducted by Yakov Kreizberg
None of the foregoing [critical comments on the
merits of the Concerto] can be applied to the
Armenian soloist Karine Georgian: her musicianly
virtuosity was full of insights, seldom becoming
aggressive but with a true Slav singing tone,
radiant with royally blazing majesty.
NRC Handelsblad
Britten Cello Symphony (Australian premiere)
Sydney Symphony Orchestra conducted by Vladimir Verbitsky
Lyrical passages, lying high and with a long line
are what the cello usually demands in a concerto.
Denying his soloist that territory, Britten
explores a tonality, in fact a whole dimension of
cello playing that is densely modernistic. The
result is a work worthy of our intense
concentration when played with the commitment that
Verbitsky and his soloist, Karine Georgian,
brought to it. Georgian does not have the biggest
sound among cellists, but she digs her bow deep
into the strings to achieve the muscularity that
Britten mostly demands. When, later in the work,
some singing is permitted to the cello, Georgian
sounds positively liberated.
Sun-Herald
Lalo Cello Concerto in D minor
National Opera Orchestra of Belgium, conducted by Sylvain Cambreling
The cello-phenomenon Karine Georgian made a
thoroughly convincing case for the melodic power
of Edouard Lalos Concerto in D minor for
cello and orchestra.
Frankfurter Rundschau
Tigran Mansurian Cello Concerto No. 2 (US premiere)
SinfoNovo Boston conducted by Aram Gharabekian
Mansurians concerto is an intense and tragic
work composed in 1978 for the cellist Karine
Georgian; now living in England she was the
soloist again Saturday night, an occasion of
moving reunion with the composer, who was able to
come from Armenia for the performance. Music is an
international language, but it is a national one
too this music comes from the heritage of
Armenian folk song and dance and, in the most
interesting section, the second movement, from the
patterns and inflections of Armenian speech. The
music expresses not only tragedy but resilience
and defiance; Georgians performance was of
great instrumental mastery and unfettered emotion.
It was deeply moving to share the experience of
community expressed in the music and felt by an
audience across the world. All those legislators
who dismiss the arts as entertainment
and frills should have been there.
Richard Dyer, Boston Globe
Prokofiev Symphony-Concerto
BBC Symphony Orchestra conducted by Sir Edward Downes, Royal Festival Hall
I heard the last two
concerts of the series [all the symphonies of
Prokofiev] comprising the fifth, sixth and seventh
symphonies, along with the beautiful Sinfonia
Concertante Op 125 (a recasting of the 1938 cello
concerto) performed with supreme eloquence by
soloist Karine Georgian.
Paul Driver, Sunday Times
Tippett Triple Concerto
London Sinfonietta conducted by David Atherton, Queen Elizabeth Hall
A wonderfully poetic account of the Triple
Concerto at a Royal Festival Hall concert to mark
Sir Michael Tippetts 80th birthday.
Andrew Clements, Guardian
London Sinfonietta conducted by David Atherton, Queen Elizabeth Hall
One of the pleasures of the BBC Radio Classics
series is re-encountering concerts remembered from
the original broadcast. In this case the
experience is even more uncanny: I was at this
80th birthday tribute to Sir Michael Tippett and
remember his praise for the performers in a brief
speech afterwards. Re-acquaintance confirms that
this was the best performance of the Triple
Concerto I had heard; 11 years on it remains so.
Incisive, cogent, supremely articulate and full of
momentum, it gathers the musics threads more
securely than, say, the composers own
accounts, yet there is no lack of warmth and
tenderness. The slow movement strikes a perfect
balance between the soloists [Ernst Kovavic,
violin; Rivka Golani, viola; Karine Georgian,
cello] English lyricism and the exotic, nocturnal
chimes of the orchestra, with climaxes more
menacing than usual.
Brian Hunt, Daily Telegraph
Recitals and Chamber Music
Herkulessaal, Munich (with Ralf Gothoni)
From the very first bars of Beethovens Magic
Flute Variations it was clear that the cellist
Karine Georgian and her pianist Ralf Gothoni were
going to give audience in the Herkulessaal a great
evening. Karine Georgian, born in Moscow and a
student of, among others, Rostropovich, winner of
the First Prize in the Tchaikovsky Competition, is
a fabulous cellist who reminds us once again how
many great interpreters, not merely pianists, come
from the Soviet Union. She unites all the virtues
of a musician: temperament and freshness,
musicality and intelligence, taste and elegance,
spot-on intonation and convincing phrasing. This
compendium of talents finds its counterpart in her
playing: the freshness not slapdash, the
temperament never excessive. She takes risks, too,
but always has them under control.
We had no brooding melancholy in this evening, no
morose longueurs. All of it was exciting
music-making, entertaining in the best sense of
the word. In Bartoks Romanian Dances Karine
Georgian crossed rhythms with magnificent aplomb,
just as she savoured with evident enjoyment the
blue notes as jazz musicians call them, not
precisely a major or a minor third, but a slight
bending between the two. All these technical
devices, realised with the utmost technical and
musical mastery, belonged perfectly to the
programme, something that one can all too rarely
say.
Süddeutsche Zeitung
Queen Elizabeth Hall, London (with Pavel Gililov)
On Sunday afternoon another effortlessly musical
artist played to an Elizabeth Hall audience. The
Armenian cellist Karine Georgian brought a
programme in which only one work, Debussys
Sonata, was out of the instruments
mainstream repertory; even the Brahms Sonata in D
proved to be an arrangement by the composer of the
Violin Sonata in G Op 78, appropriately
transposed. Everything Georgian plays is presented
with the most succulent glowing tone, the phrasing
boundlessly ample. That can be too much of a good
thing in the Debussy, the first movement
was just a little over-emphatic, but the exuberant
transition from slow movement to finale was quite
irresistible. With her fine partner Pavel Gililov
and some generously measured tempi she turned the
Brahms sonata into a big, rangey work and then
turned her attention to two small solo pieces
Dutilleuxs ruminative Trois strophes
sur le nom de Sacher, and the first performance
here of a Capriccio by her fellow countryman
Tigran Mansurian, which in its folk-tinged
nostalgia seemed perfectly judged for its
dedicatees sustained eloquence.
Andrew Clements, Financial Times
Lobanov, Mansurian
Almeida Festival, London
The two most substantial figures figures presented
seem to have been Vasily Lobanov and Tigran
Mansurian; both had written new pieces inspired by
the Armenian earthquake. Lobanovs Second
Sonata, learnt at very short notice by Karine
Georgian and beautifully played, concentrated its
laments into constricted themes reminiscent of
Debussys Footprints in the Snow.
Mansurians Tombeau, also played with emotion
by Georgian, movingly included echoes of the
playing of a 12-year old violinist, in whose
memory the piece was written.
Nicholas Kenyon, The Observer
There were two impressive Soviet pianists (Alexei
Lyubimov and the composer Vasily Lobanov) and
three wonderful cellists, Natalia Gutman, Ivan
Monighetti and Karine Georgian, the last-named of
whom gave the world premiere of Lobanovs
moving Second Cello Sonata, an Almeida commission
in memory of the Armenian earthquake.
Music and Musicians
It was Rostropovichs best playing of
intricate 20th century music that came to mind as
Miss Georgian sailed through the treacherous,
encyclopaedic solo sonata of Kodály
the work of a musician who has absorbed the
material and identified with it fully.
Will Crutchley, New York Times
[Kodály Sonata for solo cello] Rarely do
forces of music, energy and idea find themselves
so powerfully in alliance within a single
individual. The most arresting feature of Karine
Georgians playing is the strength and
fluidity of her bow arm a consummately
controlled channel for the outpouring of a musical
mind that is passionate, inventive, spontaneous,
yet carefully reasoned and serenely assured.
Boston Globe
International Leonard Rose Competition and Festival, Washington DC
Another virtuoso showpiece, Zoltan Kodály#146;s Sonata Op 8 for unaccompanied
cello, was handled with reverence and conviction
by Karine Georgian. Among the first contributions
to a significant body of 20th century solo cello
music, the sonata makes use of every sound effect
in the book and then some. All were rendered with
tremendous expressivity.
Washington Post
Holywell Music Room, Oxford (with Stephen Gutman)
When a musician is so clearly in love with her
voice whether projected by an instrument or
the vocal chords and when that voice is a
repository of infinite variety of colour and
emotional expression, how can an audience not
follow wherever she chooses to go? There was
scarcely a moment when one was aware of the two
factors, Karine Georgian and Karine
Georgians cello, that were creating the
glorious sounds in the Holywell Music Room, so
completely at one were they.
Oxford Times
Gililov-Tretyakov-Georgian Trio
Three internationally renowned musicians, Pavel Gililov (piano), Viktor
Tretyakov (violin) and Karine Georgian (cello) inspired and electrified the
enthusiastic audience with their performances of Beethovens Ghost, Dvoraks
Dumky and Shostakovichs Second Trios.
Kölner Stadt-Anzeiger
Over three evenings the Russian cellist Karine
Georgian performed all six suites for solo cello
by Bach a Herculean task. Hers was a
reading which swept away all stylistic
superfluities and penetrated to the heart of the
music. A radiant sound and for the most part a
choice of deliberate tempi enhanced the stature of
these works. Moments such as the approach to the
final cadence in both parts of the Sarabande of
the Second Suite had a grandeur one seldom hears
these days. A richly rewarding experience.
Eastern Daily Press
Rich and strong, with a dash of something a little
sharper for the Minuets, Bachs Second Cello
Suite made a most civilised start to a solo
recital by Karine Georgian. A pupil of
Rostropovich, she showed his influence not only in
manner and choice of repertoire, but also in
formidable technique and utter commitment. She
continued with Pendereckis 1986 tribute to
the great Russian cellist, exploring all the
psychological depths of Per Slava as it rose from
the quietly hesitant questioning in its opening to
an alarming peak of turbulence before finding a
more harmonious conclusion. Next came Howard
Skemptons Arioso. This was a new work
specially composed to dovetail into this
particular programme, after the emotionality of
what had gone before and the rich complexities of
Brittens technically demanding Cello Suite
No. 3 that very satisfyingly followed. A miniature
no more than three minutes long, Arioso was
pensive rather than rhetorical in nature,
presenting one attractive melodic figure that held
the attention. Karine Georgian interpreted it in a
light, clear tone with the apparent ease of high
artistry.
Norwich Evening News
Chamber Music at Tübinger Festsaal (with Pavel Gililov and Viktor Tretyakov)
In Karine Georgian the audience at the Festsaal
encountered a fascinating personality. This former
student of Rostropovich, who now teaches at the
Hochschule in Detmold, proved to be the most
refined imaginable interpreter of the Sonata in G
major Op 58 of Mendelssohn, of which it is
difficult to conceive a more perfect performance
being heard. It would not be quite right to say
that in their sonata performances the artists
occasionally overstepped the limits of chamber
music, but it was nevertheless apparent how very
much the orchestral style of Brahms Trio in
B Op 8 became them. To this piece they brought the
ultimate in refined articulation and phrasing, and
over and above these qualities a scarcely
containable joy in music-making; they drew on
seemingly limitless resources without ever losing
control of their excesses. Thunderous
applause was followed by an encore: a calming slow
piece also, naturally, by Brahms.
Südwest-Presse Schwäbischer Tagblatt
New York, with Sahan Arzruni
The latest installment in the Town Hall series of Russian
Nights was an estimable and sometimes exciting recital by
the cellist Karine Georgian. Russian Nights is a
misnomer, though doubtless more salable than Soviet
Nights would be, since both Miss Georgian and her
accompanist, Sahan Arzruni, are Armenian. One cannot thank
the cellists heritage alone for her avoidance of the
hyper-muscular, sometimes harsh style of string playing
associated with Russian players in recent decades, for one
of her teachers was Mstislav Rostropovich, Russian to the
core, who transcends any such limitations himself. And it
was Mr. Rostropovichs best playing of intricate
20th-century music that came to mind as Miss Georgian sailed
through the treacherous, encyclopedic solo sonata of Zoltan
Kodaly Friday evening.
This is a piece that demands not only the most sophisticated
command of technical special effects, but also something
like a conductors concentrated control of a long musical
span, since shape and motion must be generated without the
assistance of accompaniment or the anchoring inevitability
of Bachs contrapuntal essays. Miss Georgian has the work
securely in hand, and has a showpiece in it. Her pointing of
the dialogues between the upper and lower strings; her
questioning, exploratory sounding of the plaintive passages,
and her relish for the virtuoso finale were all the work of
a musician who has absorbed the material and identified with
it fully.
Much was also impressive in her traversal of Beethovens
G-minor sonata (pensive and carefully judged, just
occasionally lapsing into harshness at fortissimo) and
Schumanns Fantasy Pieces, Op. 73 (begun with lovely songful
freshness). Mr. Azruni was a good partner in many ways, but
his tone was too reticent and at times in the Beethoven his
passagework hovered between fairylike fleetness and
throwaway. Also on the program was a sonata by Tigran
Mansurian. On first encounter its virtues seemed steeply
outweighed by a lack of convincing motive power: it
alternated between rather dreary recitative-like exchanges
and a movement spun out in regular, singsong rhythms.
Will Crutchfield, New York Times 18 January 18, 1988